Bill would give organ donors tax breaks
Original story published 2024-09-17 13:47:53
STORY SUMMARY
A new proposal aims to address the pressing issue of kidney donation shortages in the United States, where 12 people die each day waiting for a transplant. Dr. John Roberts, a kidney transplant surgeon, highlights the dire situation, stating that over 125,000 individuals are currently on the waiting list. Representative Josh Harder has introduced a bill proposing a financial incentive of $50,000 in tax credits over five years to encourage living donations, which are notably more effective than deceased donations. Living donors often face significant hardships, including major surgery and time off work, making the incentive a potential game-changer. While the proposal faces ethical scrutiny and aims to avoid direct payment for organs, it seeks to increase the low rate of stranger donations, currently under 5%. Harder argues this measure could save billions in healthcare costs and is advocating for bipartisan support as the bill moves through committee.
VIDEO
FULL STORY
In the United States, the pressing demand for kidney transplants has led to a proposal aiming to increase living donations through financial incentives. As it stands, 12 individuals lose their lives daily while waiting for a kidney transplant, and while living donations can be significantly more effective, they remain uncommon. Dr. John Roberts, a specialist in kidney transplants, highlights that around 125,000 people are currently on the waiting list, with survival rates for those awaiting transplants being alarmingly low, even worse than leukemia.
Representative Josh Harder has introduced a bill advocating for a substantial financial incentive to encourage living kidney donations. The proposed legislation suggests offering living donors $50,000 in tax credits over five years. Harder emphasizes that potential donors face numerous challenges, including taking time off work and undergoing major surgery, and believes that some form of financial compensation is necessary. He acknowledges concerns about the proposal resembling illegal payments for organ donations but underscores the urgency due to the critical shortage of donors.
Harder’s proposal has sparked a debate, with Dr. Roberts supporting the measure despite its controversial nature. He believes that incentivizing donations is essential to saving lives, given the dire circumstances of those on the waiting list. Additionally, Harder argues that the bill, currently in committee, could significantly reduce healthcare costs associated with treating patients awaiting transplants. Efforts are now underway to gather bipartisan support to forward this potentially life-saving initiative.
