Saturday, June 6, 2020

Euthanasia and Organ Transplants

This is a very touchy subject here in America. It seems that nobody wants to address the issue. The physicians are still hesitant to consult palliative care. It could be because it represents failure of modern medicine for some. Privately, a lot of people are in favor of euthanasia, or assisted suicide, for chronically ill people. How often have you heard, If one day I am in this or that condition please pull the plug. In some countries, especially in Europe, euthanasia is legal, not without creating controversy thought. One specific country has found a way to make it more compassionate. In Belgium where euthanasia is legal, they use organs from the chronically ill that are deemed good quality for transplantation. Of course, they don’t do that with cancer patients. In a span of three years, from January 2007 to December 2009 they were able to recover 4 lungs suitable for lung transplant according to Dirk van Raemdonck and colleagues. During that span they also recovered kidneys and livers who were good enough for organ transplants.

How does it work?

Obviously, everything happens in a control environment and it works the same way as donation after cardiac death. The patient wishing for euthanasia, who has a non-malignant disorder, is given the drugs by a physician.  Once the heart stops beating, the patient is pronounced on cardiopulmonary criteria by three independent physicians. Then the patient is brought to the OR where they start the surgery to recover the organs.

Even if euthanasia would become legal here in this country, I don’t expect many potential organ donor since those patients, for the most part, have been sick for years and their organs may not be good. But, it is something to keep in mind for the future and will certainly require a comprehensive ethical debate. Not sure we are ready for that here.

Source: Transplantation of lungs: recovered from donors after euthanasia
Pierre Luc Charland
Pierre Luc Charland
Aside from being a very experienced transplant coordinator in the Houston area, Pierre is also an amazing content creator for our properties. Pierre plays a key role in driving our mission and offering expert insight to the ever evolving world of transplantation.

Facebook Comments


Must Read

How One Doctor Saved His Own Life

Transplant News Sharing // News from Source ...

Morcombes and DV prevention advocate among eight new Queensland Greats

Transplant News Sharing // News from Source Eight other individuals and organisations were also honoured as part of the annual Queensland Day celebrations, Premier...

Ganga Ram told to admit more patients, but can’t test for Covid

Transplant News Sharing // News from Source Written by Astha Saxena | New Delhi | Published: June 6, 2020 4:01:59 am Screened:...

Fred Hutch and Seattle Cancer Care Alliance share guidance with employees who are protesting during the Seattle COVID-19 Pandemic

Transplant News Sharing // News from Source SEATTLE — June 5, 2020 — The murder of Mr. George Floyd has once again brought the...

Cord blood for stem cell transplant may outperform matched sibling donor

Transplant News Sharing // News from Source IMAGE: Jonathan Gutman, MD, and colleagues show that...